Your Sales Team Isn't Ignoring Your Strategy. They're Following Their Payslip.

A framework for diagnosing when hotel sales incentive plans contradict commercial strategy, using a "Pay Map" to identify behaviours that are paid, ignored, or inadvertently punished.

Your Sales Team Isn't Ignoring Your Strategy. They're Following Their Payslip.

Photo by The Sales Leadership Brief

Your sales team isn't ignoring your strategy.

They're following their payslip.

And the two stopped agreeing some time ago, probably before you arrived.

It is the last week of the quarter. A sales manager sits at ninety-four per cent of target. A two-hundred-room-night group is on the table at a rate well below what those dates would fetch on their own. Revenue objects. The strategy agreed in January says protect rate on high-demand dates.

The manager pushes for the group anyway, wins the argument because the month looks soft, and closes at a 103%.

On Monday, the leadership team discusses rate discipline. Someone proposes negotiation training. Nobody mentions that the seller's bonus was triggered at 100% of revenue, that the group carried them over the line, and that the hotel has just paid for the decision it is now criticising.

That was not indiscipline

When sellers discount too easily, fill the wrong dates or neglect the accounts that take a year to land, leaders reach for two explanations. They lack skill, so we train them. They lack discipline, so we supervise them. Both put the fault in the person.

The less comfortable explanation is that the sales manager was obedient. Their employer gave them two documents. The strategy came with slides. The incentive plan came with money. Where the two disagree, a sensible adult follows the one that pays the school fees.

The two documents also age differently. The strategy is rewritten every year, usually by the people in that Monday meeting. The incentive plan is usually inherited. It was built for a hotel that wanted volume, by people who have since moved on, and each year it receives a new target but rarely a new logic. So the strategy moves and the plan stays where it was.

An old problem, well documented

The idea is not mine. Steven Kerr named it in 1975 in a paper called "On the Folly of Rewarding A, While Hoping for B". Organisations reward the behaviour they want to discourage, leave the behaviour they want unrewarded, and then act surprised. Part of his explanation was that organisations pay for what is easy to count.

Hotels do this in a particular way. When HSMAI and ZS studied the incentive plans of 39 hotel management companies in 2019, 81 per cent of sales managers were paid primarily on their individual revenue contribution. That is the fact. My reading of it is that revenue is a fair thing to pay for and a blunt one. It counts a room night that displaces better business the same as one that doesn't. It cannot tell the seller who held the line from the one who gave way.

The people inside these plans appear to agree. In a 2015 ZS survey of 522 hotel sales and revenue professionals for the HSMAI Foundation, only 20 per cent of sales executives said they were likely to recommend their own incentive plan to a peer. Both studies are North American and neither is recent, so I take them as direction, not measurement.

The Pay Map

Every behaviour in a sales team sits in one of three zones. I call the picture the Pay Map. It fits on one page, drawn with the incentive plan and last year's payout sheet beside you.

Paid. What the plan literally measures. If that is room revenue against a quarterly target, the hotel is buying room revenue by the quarter, at any rate, on any dates, from any customer. You will get more of whatever sits here, whether you want it or not.

Ignored. What the strategy asks for and the plan cannot see. Opening an account that won't produce for a year. Passing a lead to a colleague better placed to win it. Coaching a junior. These survive on goodwill. Your best people supply it for a while, and then they notice who is being paid.

Punished. What the strategy asks for and the plan charges for. The seller who declines the low-rated group misses the threshold. The one who forecasts honestly inherits a higher target. The one who spends a quarter opening a new segment falls behind the colleague who farmed old accounts. Leaders rarely look in this zone, and it explains most of what they complain about on Monday.

Now draw your own. Write down the five behaviours your strategy depends on most. For most hotels the list includes holding rate under pressure, declining business that displaces better business, opening new accounts, sharing leads and forecasting honestly. Put each one in its zone, using the plan as it is written and not as it was intended.

Be strict about the test. A behaviour is Paid only if doing more of it raises the payout. It is Punished if doing it can lower the payout. Everything the plan is silent on is Ignored, however often it is applauded in meetings. Praise is not pay.

In most plans I have seen, one or two land in Paid. The rest are Ignored or Punished.

What it costs

The commercial cost is the visible one: the discount, the displaced dates, the new-account pipeline that never fills.

The human cost is slower and worse. The careful sales person watches the careless one collect the larger bonus. I wrote some months ago that the best salespeople don't quit for money, and that one reason they go is effort nobody sees. The Pay Map is that argument with the payout sheet open. When holding the line earns less than giving way, you have told both sellers what you value, in the only language that leaves no room for interpretation. One of them adjusts. The other updates a CV.

What to do on Monday

Empty the Punished zone first. No reward you add will outweigh a penalty you leave in place. If saying no to the wrong group costs a seller the bonus, give them a way to decline that doesn't: a displacement credit, or a target adjustment agreed with Revenue at the time.

Then move one behaviour from Ignored to Paid. One, not five. Choose the behaviour the strategy leans on hardest. For many hotels that is rate quality, paid as revenue above a floor rate or weighted towards need dates. A single change that sellers can explain to each other in the corridor beats a twelve-metric scorecard nobody can calculate.

Expect the new measure to be gamed, because every measure is. Pay on rate and someone will turn away good volume. Pay on new accounts and someone will open ten that never book. That is the reason to move one behaviour at a time, and to redraw the map after two quarters with the payout sheet beside you again.

None of this is a case for paying more. It is a case for paying on purpose.

The ten-minute test

Take last year's payouts and put two names side by side: the seller you most want the rest of the team to copy, and the seller who earned the most.

If they are the same person, your map is in good order. If they are not, your plan and your strategy disagree, and your team has known it for longer than you have.

A strategy that isn't in the incentive plan is an opinion. Revenue follows clarity, and nothing in a hotel is clearer than what it pays for.

What is one behaviour you have watched a hotel punish without meaning to?

It mirrors "Which layer broke first?" from your best performer: it asks for a memory tied to the framework. It also lets a reader answer about any hotel, past or present, without criticising their current employer.

Sources

  • Kerr, S. (1975). "On the Folly of Rewarding A, While Hoping for B." Academy of Management Journal, 18(4), 769-783. Citation checked via Talking About Organizations.

  • HSMAI and ZS, Hotel Management Company Incentive Plan Research Report, released 2 October 2019: Hospitality Net. Source for 39 companies and 81%.

  • ZS and HSMAI Foundation, Hotel Sales Incentive Practices Research Study, reported 12 May 2015: SHRM. Source for 522 respondents and 20%.

View story source
Finance Operations & Strategy Human Resources Revenue Management Marketing Alignment Sales Incentives Rate Discipline

Comments

Comments for this content

0 comments available
Loading comments...