Chapter 7 — Three Things at Breakfast

Ask most owners where their breakfast food cost problem lives and they will point at the kitchen, the supplier, or the person setting up the buffet at five in the morning. In my experience, they are almost always pointing in the wrong direction. 

The real leak is usually the door. It comes down to one simple question that nobody at the property is asking: is the person reaching for that second waffle actually a guest of the hotel? When that question gets answered cleanly every morning, the numbers fall into line. When it doesn't, your waste log becomes the place where the losses go to hide. 

This week's story is about a 130-room property where the breakfast cost per occupied room had been climbing for two years. The owner blamed the breakfast attendant. The GM blamed the breakfast attendant. Meanwhile, the breakfast attendant — a woman named Rosa who had been running that room since 2012 — knew exactly where the money was going. She had it written down in a notebook. Neighbors wandering in from the apartment complex next door. A sales rep with a cooler. A guest with a five-year compensation habit nobody was tracking. About $18,000 a year, walking out the door with a smile.

Then a new GM showed up on a Tuesday morning, sat in the corner with a cup of coffee for ninety minutes, and saw it all for herself. What she did over the next ninety days cut the breakfast cost per occupied room by 21 percent — without a single hard word to a guest.

It's a story about controls, but more than that it's a story about listening to your people. The cheapest control in the building is a conversation with the person who runs the room.

Grab a coffee and read on. And if you have ever worked a breakfast shift, I promise you already know these characters.

If you have ever worked a continental breakfast shift in a limited-service hotel, you already know what I am about to write about. You know the regulars by face before you know their names. You know the trick the guy in the gray pickup pulls with his cooler. You know which family shows up four people deep on a one-room reservation. You know which guest threatens the one-star review every time, and you know which front desk associate folds every time. You know what the food cost number is going to look like at the end of the month before anybody runs the report. And you know that nobody at the property is going to do anything about any of it, because nobody at the property has worked a breakfast shift since the building opened.

This chapter is about a breakfast attendant named Rosa, a property whose owner thought the food cost problem was Rosa, and a new general manager who solved it in ninety minutes by getting up early and sitting in the corner with a cup of coffee.

The property had a hundred and thirty rooms. Suburban market in the Mid-Atlantic, off a highway exit, the kind of building that is mostly business travel Monday through Wednesday and weddings on Saturday. The hotel had been there for eighteen years. The breakfast cost per occupied room had been climbing for two years and was now sixty-two cents above the brand target. The owner, a man who lived three states away and reviewed the financials every Friday, had spent eight straight months telling the GM the breakfast program was bleeding. The GM had spent the same eight months telling Rosa the breakfast program was bleeding. Rosa had spent the same eight months telling the GM exactly why, and getting nowhere.

Rosa had been at the property since 2012. She arrived at five-fifteen every morning, started the coffee at five-twenty, set up the buffet by six, and ran the room until ten with a smile on her face that did not know how to come off. She knew every repeat guest by name. She knew the kids of the wedding parties. She knew how the woman in 224 took her oatmeal. She also knew, by face, every regular abuser the property had quietly absorbed for years. She had been writing them down in a small notebook she kept under the cash drawer. She had given the notebook to the GM in December. The GM had filed it.

Let me tell you who was in that notebook.

There were three people from Brookside Apartments next door. A retired couple who walked in every morning at seven-fifteen, ate breakfast, and walked out twenty-five minutes later. They were not staying at the hotel. They had not stayed at the hotel in the eight months Rosa had been counting them. The third person was a younger man who came in around the same time three or four mornings a week. He always took breakfast to go in a cardboard tray. None of the three had ever produced a room number, because nobody had ever asked for one.

There was Mr. Henley, a corporate guest from a logistics company up the highway, who stayed Monday through Thursday in room 312 and brought his sister and her two children to breakfast every weekday morning before the kids went to school. The sister lived eight miles away. The children were six and nine. They were lovely kids. Mr. Henley paid for one breakfast in his rate. He brought four people to it.

There was a regional sales rep named Wade who stayed every other Tuesday. Every visit, Wade carried a small soft-sided cooler in from his pickup truck. Every visit, Wade loaded that cooler with eight yogurts, six juice boxes, four muffins, two bananas, and a stack of granola bars. He had been doing this for three years. Once, when Rosa had said something about the cooler, Wade had laughed and told her the previous GM had said it was fine.

There was Mr. Ferguson, who came in irregularly with a different friend each time, never the same friend twice. Mr. Ferguson believed, or claimed to believe, that he had been given lifetime free breakfast at the property in 2014 by a GM who had since retired. There was no documentation of any such arrangement. Mr. Ferguson had been told no by Rosa more than once. Each time, the front desk had overridden her, because the front desk did not want a scene at six-thirty in the morning.

And there was Mrs. Patrick, the woman in the notebook on the most pages. Mrs. Patrick stayed at the property four to five times a year. She brought a friend or a daughter or a sister. Every stay, Mrs. Patrick asked for the GM. Every stay, Mrs. Patrick had a complaint that escalated to a request for compensation. Every stay, the GM gave her a stack of breakfast vouchers “for the inconvenience.” Mrs. Patrick had forty-seven check-ins at the property over five years. Mrs. Patrick had received compensation, in vouchers and discounts and free nights, on forty-three of those forty-seven stays. The GM had never tracked it. Rosa had.

The combined cost of those five categories, when somebody finally added it up, was about eighteen thousand dollars a year on a property whose total breakfast budget should have been somewhere around ninety thousand. That was the food cost problem the owner had been blaming on Rosa.

In April of that year, the owner replaced the GM with a woman named Janelle. Janelle was forty-one. She had been an assistant general manager at a sister property in the same flag for seven years. Her first day at the new property was a Tuesday. She arrived at six-fifty in the morning with a black coffee from a gas station down the road. She did not introduce herself to the front desk. She did not introduce herself to Rosa. She walked into the breakfast room, took a seat in the corner by the window, and sat there for ninety minutes with the coffee, watching.

By eight-thirty she had personally observed the three people from Brookside Apartments, Mr. Henley with his sister and the two children, the regional sales rep with the soft-sided cooler, Mr. Ferguson with a man Rosa had never seen before, and one previously unflagged extended-stay guest who quietly filled a Tupperware container with bacon and pastries and walked it back to her room. Janelle wrote each one down on the back of her napkin. Then she got up, walked into the back, found Rosa unloading a delivery of yogurts, and said, “Walk me through who in this room shouldn’t be here.”

Rosa cried for about ninety seconds. Then she pulled the notebook out from under the cash drawer.

Here is what Janelle did over the next ninety days.

She went to the front desk and built a process. Every guest at check-in received a small card with their room number and the breakfast service hours printed on it. The card was the price of admission. Rosa stood at the breakfast room entrance every morning until seven, the busiest hour, and politely asked every guest she did not recognize for a room number. The card was not a wristband. It was not a turnstile. It was a friendly piece of paper. The first three mornings, the people from Brookside Apartments showed up, were greeted with a smile and a question, did not have an answer, said they would be back, and never came back. The retired couple, in fairness, did stay at the property one weekend a few months later as paying guests. They paid for breakfast that weekend. Rosa hugged them both.

For Mr. Henley, Janelle built a “Family Breakfast Add-On.” It was a small daily charge that allowed an extended-stay guest to bring up to three additional family members to breakfast. It was reasonable, it was friendly, and it was metered. Mr. Henley bought it for one stay, decided he did not actually want to pay for it, and moved his sister and the kids to the cafe across the parking lot. He continued to stay at the property for three more years.

For Wade and the cooler, Janelle and Rosa rehearsed a sentence together, which Rosa delivered with warmth the next time he came through the line. The sentence was, “Wade, the breakfast room is for in-room enjoyment, not for the road. We made you up a coffee and a muffin for your drive. Thank you for understanding.” Wade laughed. He stopped bringing the cooler.

For Mr. Ferguson, Janelle called the previous GM, who had moved on but answered the phone. The previous GM told her the truth, which was that he had given Mr. Ferguson a single complimentary breakfast in 2014 after a hot water issue, and that the rest of it was a story Mr. Ferguson had grown over the years on his own. Janelle wrote a polite letter that thanked him for his loyalty, explained the property’s comp authorization policy, and offered him a single complimentary breakfast on his next stay as a courtesy. Mr. Ferguson wrote a long, angry email to corporate. Corporate sided with Janelle. Mr. Ferguson came back six months later, alone, paid for his stay, and ate breakfast quietly.

For Mrs. Patrick, Janelle called her at home on a Thursday afternoon. She introduced herself as the new GM. She thanked Mrs. Patrick for her loyalty. She explained, gently and clearly, that future service-recovery situations would be handled by the GM personally, with documentation, on a Service Recovery Credit form, and not through breakfast vouchers at the desk. Mrs. Patrick was quiet on the phone for a long moment. Then she said, “Well, all right then,” and hung up. She booked another stay four months later. She did not ask for the GM. She did not ask for compensation.

Within ninety days the breakfast cost per occupied room had dropped twenty-one percent. The Daily Waste Log started telling the truth, because the waste was now actual waste and not theft in the disguise of waste. The brand’s monthly Breakfast Standards Checklist came back clean for the first time in two years, because Rosa was no longer running the room while half her inventory was walking out the door. The Approved Vendor List did not change at all. The Breakfast Cost Per Occupied Room Report, which had been hidden in the back office for years, was printed and posted on the inside of the supply room door where Rosa could see it every morning. Rosa got a raise. Janelle called her in to give it to her, in person, at the start of the second month.

Here is what Section Seven is really about.

Section Seven looks like a food cost section. It is not. It is a hospitality-with-a-spine section. The Approved Vendor List for breakfast suppliers, the order quantities tied to the occupancy forecast, the Breakfast Cost Per Occupied Room calculation, the Daily Waste Log, the brand standards checklist — those are real controls and they belong in the manual. But the most expensive control failure in a breakfast program is almost never about the staff or the supplier or the order quantity. It is about the door. It is about the front desk and the breakfast attendant having one shared answer to a single question, which is whether the person now reaching for the second waffle is a guest of the hotel. When that question is answered cleanly, every other number in the program will fall into line. When it is not, the Daily Waste Log becomes the room where the property’s losses go to live anonymously.

There is one more thing I will say. Rosa told the previous GM about every one of these abusers, in writing, in a notebook with her name on the cover, twelve months before Janelle showed up. The notebook had been filed. That was the cheapest control failure in the building. Listening to your breakfast attendant costs nothing and saves more money than most owners will believe.

The Internal Control Review on Section Seven is now run at this property every March, between the brand QA inspection and the spring shoulder season. It has caught small things every year. None of them have been an eighteen-thousand-dollar thing.

A breakfast program runs on three things. Fresh fruit. Hot coffee. And the front desk knowing who got a key last night.

About This Book and the Manual Behind It

Hotel Franchisees' Guide to Everyday Internal Controls is a companion to the full-service Hotel Financial Coach Finance & Accounting Policies Manual — it has twenty sections, one hundred and forty-four numbered policies, and roughly fifty supporting forms, all built on USALI, U.S. GAAP, and the COSO internal control framework.

The manual is the working document. The book is the way you actually understand it — one chapter per section, one true story per chapter, each one walking through what goes wrong at a real property when the controls in that section are missing. Cash. Accounts receivable. Payroll. Night audit. PCI. Brand compliance. All twenty.

The operating arm of the manual is the Internal Control Review — a twelve-month rotating self-audit that puts every section on a calendar and keeps it there. The First Hundred Days Implementation Checklist gets your property from day one to the start of your first ICR rotation, in five phases, with a signed artifact at every milestone.

The central idea is simple: most of what goes wrong at a hotel goes wrong because nobody was looking at a calendar. The manual is the calendar made permanent. The ICR is the calendar made annual. The book is the calendar made memorable.

If any of this sounds like your property, send me an email. I'm happy to point you in the right direction.

****For a Limited Time - Send me an Email and I'll Send you My New Book - The Hotel Franchisees' Guide to Everyday Internal Controls - "You Don't Need to Be An Accountant to Be In Control" at [email protected]

The Prosperous Hotelier Book on Amazon - https://a.co/d/971dCOv

The Hotel Financial Coach Website - https://www.hotelfinancialcoach.com/

Full Service Hotel Accounting Policy Manual – FAQ & Free Samples 
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1m6dB_bKK9IdSRmFO7wXJ7rtnTRfmANZv/view?usp=sharing