Tourist tax is coming. Where’s the plan?
The decision has been made. An overnight visitor levy in England. Now comes the test: can mayors make it work for hospitality and prove it’s worth paying? Here’s what hoteliers think.
England's incoming overnight visitor levy prompts hoteliers to demand transparent spending plans, with UKHospitality warning a 5% levy could cost 11.9 million visitor nights and 33,000 jobs.
Photo by Hoteliers' Voice Podcast/ Haynes MarComs Ltd
“If you want to grow tourism in the UK, why are you making it more expensive?”
It's a fair question. And it's one Paul Hunter, General Manager at Hotham Hall Estate, put to the debate around England's new 'tourist tax' at a recent Roundtable Roadshow hosted by Hoteliers' Voice.
The government has given mayors and eligible local leaders the power to introduce an overnight stay levy. It’s a done deal. The question is no longer whether the policy is coming, but whether those introducing it can make the numbers stack up.
There are plenty of reasons to support investment in tourism. Better infrastructure, cleaner public spaces and stronger attractions benefit visitors, residents and hospitality businesses alike. But an extra charge on overnight stays also brings risks, from higher costs for guests to questions over competitiveness and how the money will be spent.
As I gathered with hoteliers to discuss the issue, one thing became clear: the industry isn't simply asking whether visitors should pay more. It's asking what, exactly, they'll be paying for.
The risk of pricing visitors out
The levy is driven by some tempting projections of the money that could be generated. Up to £40 million for Greater Manchester. The possibility of £52 million for York and North Yorkshire. A cool £350 million a year in London. It’s eye-watering. But will these be tears of joy or despair for hoteliers?
Paul questioned the revenue projections being discussed by authorities. “Goodness knows where they got the numbers from – because they seem to think every hotel in Yorkshire runs at 95% occupancy.”
If the sums rely on consistently high occupancy, how realistic are they? Forecasts need to account for seasonal fluctuations, differences between properties, and the possibility that demand could change once a levy is introduced.
Although the levy is widely considered a ‘tourist tax’, it’s not just overseas visitors who have to pay. “It's not just going to be for tourists,” said Tasneem Watson, Director at Discovery Hotels. “It's also going to be for every guest that enters your hotel.”
For hotels reliant on corporate business, that could be significant. “I wonder if some companies will reconsider whether they want to come to that destination,” said Siggi Schrott of Net Affinity. “They may have to pay an extra, let’s say £10 per night, on top of the rate.” These fees may quickly become significant.
Ultimately, increasing the cost of a hotel stay feels uncomfortable for an industry already working hard to attract guests while battling rising costs. But the concern isn't just about another charge on the bill. It's about whether that charge could make some destinations less competitive. UKHospitality has estimated that a 5% levy would result in 11.9 million fewer visitor nights, and £1.8 billion less in tourism spending in 2030. It also forecast a loss of nearly 33,000 jobs.
Nobody can say with certainty that a levy will drive visitors away. But nor should authorities assume it won't affect demand.
A levy without a spending plan?
For Mark Thurman, Managing Director of Casa Hotels Group, this is the biggest question of all. “A lot of the issue comes from: we don't know how this is going to be spent,” he said.
There is a credible argument for visitor levies. Destinations need investment in transport, public spaces, events and attractions, all of which can improve the visitor experience. Better infrastructure can benefit residents and businesses as well as tourists.
But Mark wants to know whether the money will benefit the local area or disappear into the wider regional budget. “There's no real suggestion on the specifics of how all of this revenue is going to be spent,” he said. “Will it benefit the area, or does it just benefit the cities of that particular mayoral region?”
Dan Wilson, Regional Manager at Vine Hotels, shares that concern. “It's publicly known that many councils and authorities are close to bankruptcy,” he said. “It's a concern that this would fund a different part of a pot, and not what we want it to be spent on.”
If money raised from overnight stays is intended to support the visitor economy, hoteliers want confidence that it won't simply plug unrelated budget gaps.
What can we learn from tourist taxes elsewhere?
Edinburgh's 5% visitor levy, worth a projected £50 million annually, will go towards public toilets, cultural projects, and additional city-centre policing. Amsterdam 12.5% levy (increasing to 20%) goes towards general costs associated with high visitor numbers, such as cleaning public spaces, policing, repairing infrastructure, and crowd control. Paris uses fixed charges that increase with the star rating of the accommodation type, and is spent on maintaining tourism infrastructure, public transport, and tourism development projects.
International examples show that a visitor levy can fund the places and infrastructure tourism depends on. The challenge for England is to turn the promise of new revenue into a credible plan for delivering that value.
The proof will be in the spending
The overnight visitor levy doesn't have to be a choice between supporting tourism and taxing it. Destinations need investment, and a well-designed levy could help pay for it.
But let's be clear: raising money isn't the same as creating value.
Mayors can point to impressive revenue projections, but the real measure of success won't be how much they collect. It will be whether destinations become better places to visit as a result. Cleaner streets. Better public spaces. Stronger cultural attractions. Infrastructure that works for visitors and residents alike.
That means transparent spending, realistic forecasts, and a way to measure whether the levy is actually delivering what it promises. Evidence it’s made a tangible difference.
There's another uncomfortable reality here. Hotels will be the ones explaining the additional charge to guests, answering the questions, and potentially dealing with the fallout if visitors decide their money is better spent elsewhere. They shouldn't be expected to sell a policy that its architects can't properly justify.
The levy is coming. The opportunity now is to make it work. But if mayors want visitors to pay more – and the hospitality industry to get behind it – they need to do more than tell us how much money it will raise. They need to show us what that money buys.
Because if the only thing a tourist tax delivers is more money into the public purse, while making destinations more expensive to visit, that's not investment in tourism. It's a tax on an industry expected to pick up the bill.
Comments
Comments for this content
0 comments available