Is More Green Organizational Support Always Better?

An Intriguing Finding about Perceived Green Organizational Support and Job Resourcefulness

A study of 265 employees across nine luxury hotels in the Philippines finds that stronger green organizational support narrows capability gaps but does not uniformly boost resourcefulness, suggesting targeted support works better than blanket programs.

Organizations increasingly want employees to support their sustainability goals. Many organizations communicate environmental priorities, provide green training, recognize environmentally responsible behavior, and encourage their associates to participate in sustainability initiatives.

It may seem reasonable to assume that the more organizational support employees perceive, the better. Supportive organizational environments should help employees use their knowledge, skills, and abilities more effectively. Our recent research, however, reveals a more nuanced picture.

The Research

In our recently published article, Employment Qualifications, Job Resourcefulness, and Non-Green Behavior: A Capability-Role Perspective on Environmental Management, my coauthors, Drs. Yung-Kuei Huang and R. L. Fernando Garcia, and I examined how employee capabilities and organizational conditions relate to non-green behavior at work. Non-green behavior refers to workplace behaviors that may undermine an organization's environmental objectives, such as wasting resources, ignoring environmental practices, or avoiding environmental standards when they interfere with work efficiency.

We used data from 265 employees across nine upper-upscale and luxury hotels and resorts in the Philippines operated by the same company. The study combined archival employment-qualification records with employee survey data collected at different time points. We focused on several key concepts:

  • Employment qualifications - organization-assessed capabilities such as mental ability, communication, problem-solving, work experience, resilience, and interpersonal skills, based on pre-employment assessments retrieved from HR records at Time 1.  

  • Job resourcefulness - employees' ability to overcome constraints, find creative solutions, and make things happen despite limited resources (Time 2).

  • Perceived green organizational support - employees' perceptions that their organization values and supports environmental goals (Time 2).

  • Non-green behavior - employee behaviors that may work against organizational sustainability efforts (Time 3).

Better Qualifications Can Help - Through Resourcefulness

Our results first confirmed an intuitive pattern. Employees with stronger employment qualifications tended to report higher job resourcefulness. Employees reporting greater job resourcefulness also reported less non-green behavior.

That means having capable employees matters, but capabilities alone may not be sufficient. Employees also need to translate their knowledge, experience, problem-solving abilities, and other qualifications into resourceful action when they face workplace constraints.

Then we examined whether perceived green organizational support would strengthen this relationship. That is where the results became surprising.

More Support Did Not Strengthen the Relationship

We expected that when employees perceived stronger organizational support for environmental goals, the positive relationship between employment qualifications and job resourcefulness would become even stronger. The results showed the opposite pattern.

The positive relationship between employment qualifications and job resourcefulness was weaker when perceived green organizational support was higher. At first glance, that may sound as though stronger organizational support somehow reduced employee resourcefulness. That is not what we found.

Importantly, the plotted results showed higher job resourcefulness when perceived green organizational support was stronger across the range of employment qualifications examined in our study. What changed was the size of the difference between employees with stronger and weaker qualifications.

  • When organizational support was relatively low, employment qualifications made a much bigger difference in job resourcefulness.

  • When organizational support was relatively high, that difference became smaller.

Organizational Support May Help Compensate for Capability Differences

One possible explanation is that organizational support may serve a compensatory function. Employees with stronger qualifications may already possess a broad repertoire of knowledge, experience, communication skills, and problem-solving abilities. They may therefore be relatively well equipped to respond resourcefully when they encounter workplace challenges.

Employees with comparatively lower qualifications may depend more heavily on organizational cues and support that tell them:

  • environmental goals matter;

  • managers value sustainability;

  • employees' contributions to environmental initiatives are recognized; and

  • sustainability-related challenges deserve attention and effort.

Under those conditions, organizational support may help employees who have fewer capability resources respond more resourcefully.

Importantly, our study did not directly test this compensatory mechanism, so it should be viewed as a possible explanation rather than a proven conclusion. Future research is needed to examine exactly why this pattern occurs.

Should Every Employee Receive the Same Support? 

The practical implication is not that organizations should provide less support. Rather, managers may want to think more carefully about who needs what kind of support.

Organizations should certainly establish a baseline environment in which sustainability is visibly supported. Employees need to know that environmental goals are legitimate organizational priorities. Beyond that baseline, however, uniform support may not always be the most effective strategy.

Employees who struggle to translate environmental expectations into everyday work may benefit from:

  • green-focused coaching;

  • developmental performance conversations;

  • regular environmental feedback;

  • scenario-based problem-solving exercises;

  • peer learning; and

  • additional guidance when environmental goals conflict with operational demands.

Employees who already demonstrate strong resourcefulness may need something different. Instead of increasingly detailed guidance, they may benefit from greater green-task autonomy and opportunities to propose adaptive solutions to sustainability challenges.

The Goal Is Not More Support - It Is the Right Support

Managers often assume that if organizational support is good, more support must be even better. Our findings suggest a more differentiated approach.

Our findings raise the possibility that strong organizational support may help narrow capability-related differences among employees. That possibility shifts the managerial question from:

How can we provide more support?

to:

How can we provide the right support to the employees who need it most while allowing resourceful employees enough autonomy to solve problems on their own?

Sustainability initiatives depend not only on policies and employee capabilities. They also depend on how organizations create conditions that allow different employees to succeed.

For hospitality leaders, that may mean moving beyond one-size-fits-all sustainability programs toward a more targeted approach to employee development and organizational support.

What does the right balance look like in your organization? Do all employees receive the same sustainability support, or do managers adjust coaching, feedback, resources, and autonomy according to employees' capabilities and needs?

Sustainability Human Resources Green Organizational Support Non-Green Behavior Job Resourcefulness Employee Capabilities

Linchi Kwok is a Stanford/Elsevier World's Top 2% Scientist, Department Chair, and Professor at The Collins College of Hospitality Management at Cal Poly Pomona. A recognized thought leader in hospitality and tourism, he conducts research on hospitality management, service marketing, and emerging technologies, with work published in leading academic journals and cited by major media outlets.

Comments

Comments for this content

0 comments available
Loading comments...