Who pays when an AI agent books the wrong rate? Visa says the guest. Citi says the AI company.

Visa's rulebook makes the guest responsible for everything her AI agent buys. Citi, Amex and the AI companies point elsewhere, and the dispute still goes to whoever charged her card

Visa, Citi, Amex, and AI companies each give different answers on who bears liability when an AI agent books the wrong hotel rate, leaving hotels exposed until card networks settle the rules.

Who pays when an AI agent books the wrong rate? Visa says the guest. Citi says the AI company.

Photo by hospitality.today

Visa's rulebook says a guest is responsible for whatever her AI agent buys, as if she had bought it herself. Last week Citi, one of the largest card issuers in the US, said the company behind the agent should pay. American Express and the AI companies give a third and a fourth answer. None of the four has written the rule that decides a dispute.

The dispute they are arguing about is an ordinary one. Asked for two nights in Chicago at the best price, an agent books the cheapest line on the page: the non-refundable, room-only rate. The guest wanted to be able to cancel. Her plans change, the hotel points to the rate rules, and she calls her bank.

The agent followed the instruction. The hotel sold the rate it published. Nobody broke anything.

Until a rule exists, that call goes where every card dispute goes: to the business that charged the card. Often that is the hotel, and the case turns on what the hotel can show.

Visa: the guest, as if she booked it herself

Visa has written agents into its card rules. The Visa Core Rules, in the edition dated October 24, carry a section on what Visa calls agentic transactions. Rule 4.1.23.10 makes the cardholder responsible for any action the agent's provider takes as part of such a purchase. Before the agent can pay, the provider must "obtain Cardholder acknowledgement that they are responsible for actions taken by the Agentic Payment Provider."

US law leans the same way for debit cards. A transfer counts as authorized once a consumer gives an agent her card credentials, even if the agent goes beyond what she intended, the payments lawyers at Goodwin Procter wrote in June.

On paper, that favors the hotel holding the non-refundable charge. The rule settles who is responsible. It doesn't describe how a bank should decide a dispute over what the guest meant.

Citi: the company that built the agent

The guest's bank sees it differently. At the Skift Commerce Summit in New York on November 11, Abhinav Anand, who runs value cards, lending and commerce for Citi's U.S. consumer cards, named agent liability as the question banks, networks, merchants and AI companies are all trying to answer. Citi's view is that liability should fall "to the agent themselves, the company that is actually coming with the agent."

Citi was one of the first card issuers set up for agent payments with Mastercard, and more recently with Visa. The lever, as Skift reported it, is registration: an agent that wants to pay on either network might have to accept some liability when it signs up. Might. Neither network has put that in its rules.

Amex: Amex pays, once its protection is live

American Express announced Agent Purchase Protection on April 14. If a cardmember lets a registered agent buy for her, and the agent passes Amex what she actually asked for, Amex says it will protect her from charges caused by the agent's error. Seven months later, Amex's own page still describes the protection in the future tense, with the list of registered agents and the full terms "coming soon."

Two of its conditions matter to a hotel. The cardmember has to ask the merchant for a refund first, where she can. And Amex may turn down a claim where her intent is subjective or can't be verified. An instruction like "the best price" leaves room for exactly that argument. Amex hasn't said who absorbs the cost on the claims it does pay.

OpenAI and Google: the hotel stays the seller

The AI companies have put their answer in their developer documents. OpenAI's checkout documentation says that neither OpenAI nor the payment providers it works with is the merchant of record. The business actually selling and taking the payment is. Google's documentation for hotels that connect to its booking protocol tells them: "You remain the Merchant of Record for all transactions."

The merchant of record is the name on the guest's card statement, and the business that answers her dispute. We looked at what else the hotel keeps under Google's design in Hotels in the cart.

The business that charged the card gets the dispute

For a hotel, then, the answer today depends on how the booking was paid.

When Booking.com or Expedia collects the guest's money, her dispute usually starts with the OTA. The hotel may be asked for its stay records, and its own charge to the OTA's virtual card is a separate payment. When the hotel charges the guest's card itself, the dispute comes to the hotel. That covers a direct booking, a pay-at-the-hotel OTA booking and, by Google's own documentation, a booking through its protocol.

On those bookings, the case turns on paper. The rate plan the agent chose. The cancellation terms attached to it. The confirmation that went out the moment the booking was made, and whether it says non-refundable in words a guest can't miss. Visa's rule gives the hotel an argument. The confirmation is how it makes it.

What isn't settled

No hotel dispute over a booking made by an AI agent has been documented yet, and agent bookings are still a sliver of hotel volume, as we covered on November 9.

Mastercard's public operating rules don't mention agents. The company has said its standard chargeback protections apply to purchases an agent completes, BankInfoSecurity reported, and has published no agent-specific dispute rule.

Regulators haven't decided either. The UK Treasury closed a consultation on October 6 that asked whether its consent and liability rules need rewriting for agents, and has not yet answered. In the US, the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau has issued no guidance on agents. Worldpay, which processes card payments for merchants and sells them tools for agent transactions, summed up the state of play in July: no liability shift exists yet.

Read also: Hotels in the cart · Why AI agents aren't booking your rooms yet

View story source
AI in Hospitality Technology Finance Operations & Strategy Artificial Intelligence Chargebacks Agentic AI Payment Liability

Every day, millions of travel bookings move through GDS networks that most independent hotels aren't visible on. Not because they're too small. Not because the channel doesn't work for them. Because nobody told them it had changed. I write about GDS distribution specifically for independent hotels — what the channel actually looks like in 2026, who's booking on it, and what it means for properties that aren't part of a major chain.

Hospitality.today, formerly known as hotelmarketing.com, is a forward-looking platform created by Markus Busch that explores the ideas, trends, and innovations shaping the global hospitality industry. Building on the strong legacy of one of hospitality’s early digital voices, the site offers fresh perspectives on hotel marketing, technology, leadership, guest experience, and the future of travel.

Reconline is a Switzerland-based hotel technology company that helps independent hotels expand their global reach through simple, reliable GDS distribution. Based in Zermatt, Reconline connects properties to major platforms such as Amadeus, Sabre, and Travelport, making it easier for hotels to attract corporate, leisure, and travel-agency bookings without unnecessary complexity.

Comments

Comments for this content

0 comments available
Loading comments...