The Customer Service Paradox: When Better CX Doesn’t Feel Better

As AI makes service faster and frictionless, customers adapt quickly, turning improvements into baseline expectations, making human connection the key differentiator.

This article answers the question: Why can better customer service or customer experience make customers less impressed?

Answer: In an AI-fueled world, as customer service becomes faster, easier, and more efficient, customers quickly get used to the improvement, turning what once impressed them into a basic expectation. That makes the human experience more important than ever as a way to stand out.

What happens when customer service gets better, but customers are less impressed? 

There’s an old story of a plumber who is called to fix a problem. He looks at the pipes, takes out a hammer, taps one of the pipes three times, and everything starts working. He hands the customer a bill for $200. 

The customer says, “Two hundred dollars! All you did was hit a pipe with a hammer!” 

The plumber says, “I only charged you $10 for tapping the pipe. The other $190 was for knowing where to tap.” 

The lesson is simple: You’re not paying for time. You’re paying for expertise.  

But there’s an interesting paradox: The better someone gets at what they do, the easier it looks, and that can actually lower the customer’s perception of value.  

Consider another version of this story. I recently interviewed my friend and fellow CX expert Steven Van Belleghem for an upcoming Amazing Business Radio about his new book, Deep Loyalty: How to Create Lasting Customer Value in an AI-Driven World. He shared what he calls The Locksmith Paradox.  

Years ago, if you locked yourself out of your house, you might call a locksmith to help. Just like the plumber, the locksmith would show up and work on your lock. You’re charged $200, and you’re happy to pay it. You might think, “The guy worked for it.” 

Today, an experienced locksmith might get you inside your house in less than a minute. You get the bill and think, “I’m paying that much for one minute?” 

The service actually improved. It’s faster than ever. The customer doesn’t really want an hour of the locksmith’s time. They just want to get back into their house.  

Again, the lesson is simple: The better the service gets, the easier it is to take it for granted.  

Van Belleghem believes the same thing is happening with AI. 

AI helps companies answer questions faster, automate processes, eliminate friction, and, overall, make it easier for customers to do business with them. That’s a good thing. When done right, customers are impressed. But there’s a catch. 

Eventually, customers get used to this better experience. What once impressed them becomes what they expect. Another lesson: Better eventually becomes normal.  

That doesn’t mean companies should stop investing in AI or improving the experience. Customers expect and want you to, which brings us to the final lesson: Keeping up isn’t the same as standing out. 

As AI makes companies faster and more efficient, the opportunity to differentiate will increasingly come from experiences that build connection, confidence, and trust. Often that comes through interaction with a live person, making human connection even more valuable in an AI-driven world. Efficiency creates convenience. Expertise creates value. And the human experience gives customers a reason to come back.

View story source
Operations & Strategy Guest Experience Artificial Intelligence Human Connection Loyalty Programs

Comments

Comments for this content

0 comments available
Loading comments...