Where Did the Hotelier Go? How Full-Service GMs Became Administrators
Why owners and management companies run full-service hotels like limited-service hotels, and what it costs the guest, the team, and the business.
Full-service hotel GMs have been reduced to administrative roles as owners cut middle management, centralized back-office functions, and applied select-service cost targets to full-service properties.
Walk into many full-service hotels today and ask where the general manager is. The honest answer is often: in the office. Reconciling the deposit. Approving payroll. Answering corporate reports. Chasing an invoice. The person hired to run a hotel with a restaurant, a bar, banquets, meeting space, a bell stand, and a hundred moving parts is spending the day doing a clerk's work.
That is not a failure of the people in the chair. It is the result of a business model that slowly changed what a full-service hotel is, and what a GM is for.
What a Full-Service GM Used to Be
A 300-room full-service hotel runs roughly a dozen distinct operations at once: front desk, concierge, housekeeping, laundry, restaurants, bars, room service, banquets, fitness, parking, and engineering. The GM was the person who knew all of it. You were on the floor at the morning stand-up, in the lobby at check-in, in the kitchen before a banquet, and at the table with the group planner who brought you 400 room nights.
The GM set the standard by being seen. Associates learned by watching. Guests remembered a name. Operations ran smoothly because someone with authority and experience was physically present to catch a problem at 6 p.m. and not read about it in a report the next morning.
What Happened
1. The margin math pushed owners toward the limited-service model
Full-service is the most labor-intensive format in lodging. One industry guide puts it at about 2.57 labor hours per occupied room versus about 1.44 for select-service, with typical GOP margins of roughly 33-35% for full-service versus 40-50% for select-service. CBRE's Trends data showed the same pattern years ago: its select-service sample posted a 44.2% GOP margin in 2015, against 37.5% for all properties in the survey.
Owners and lenders read those numbers and ask an obvious question: why not run the big hotel the way the small hotel makes money? So, the full-service P&L started being managed to select-service targets, with fewer staff, fewer outlets, fewer hours, and fewer salaried managers.
2. The pandemic permitted owners, and most of the cuts never came back
During 2020 and 2021 hotels cut daily housekeeping, closed restaurants, and trimmed staff to survive. Then many of those cuts became policy. Host Hotels CEO Jim Risoleo told investors the industry was moving toward housekeeping as opt-in rather than opt-out. Analysts at the time said many hotels were looking at permanently reducing cleaning and breakfast service. Industry operators described grab-and-go markets inside big full-service hotels as the way forward because they need less labor and carry strong margins. At a Crescent Real Estate-affiliated hotel group, only about 34% of guests were opting in to full housekeeping.
UNITE HERE, the hotel workers' union, published a Park Hotels & Resorts list of operating priorities from November 2021 that included permanent reductions in full-time hotel-level staffing, limiting housekeeping, and eliminating or repurposing unprofitable F&B operations. That is a union's framing of the document, but the priorities themselves are the same ones owners were describing publicly.
A CoStar report from an owners' panel shows this thinking is older than the pandemic. One owner said he would get rid of F&B responsibility in full-service hotels and lease the restaurant out. Another said a free breakfast costing about $1.86 per guest beats running restaurants.
3. Centralization moved the expertise out of the hotel and the paperwork into it
Management companies and brands centralized revenue management, marketing, purchasing, and accounting. On paper that is efficient. In practice, the hotel still has to feed those systems. Someone on property has to prepare deposits, code invoices, approve payables, document everything, and answer every report. That someone is increasingly the GM, because the controller, the assistant GM, the director of operations, or the department heads who used to share the load were cut.
HVS reported in its 2026 profitability outlook that GOP margins have been declining, driven by labor, brand operating standards, and shared-service allocations, and advised owners to review centralized revenue management, marketing, and accounting fees to make sure they match the value delivered to the hotel. In other words, the cost of the centralization often lands on the property, and the work still does too.
4. Management contracts reward revenue, not the guest experience
One hospitality analyst noted that many management contracts prioritize topline performance over GOP participation through tiered incentives, so owners can see respectable occupancy and ADR growth while margins deteriorate. When incentives focus on the number, not the experience, the GM's job becomes protecting the number, which means being at the computer.
5. Fewer managers means the GM becomes the last person standing
An analysis in HOTELS magazine, summarized by Hospitality. Today, found that managing directors and GMs are increasingly pulled into operational details, staffing issues, and financial oversight because fewer experienced managers sit between leadership and the frontline. When you cut the layer below the GM, the work does not disappear. It rolls uphill, and it lands in the office.
The Industry Knows It
The clearest evidence is that management companies now say out loud this has gone too far. Newport Hospitality Group CEO Andrew Carey wrote in March 2026 that for decades managers have been pulled deeper into administrative work that keeps them behind a desk instead of building relationships with guests and associates, and that this trend needs to be reversed. His proposed fix is AI that handles reporting and data assembly, so managers get back to the lobby.
That may help. But technology can only give time back if owners and management companies decide the GM's time is worth protecting. Software does not replace a controller who was laid off, an assistant GM who was never hired, or a department head carrying three jobs.
What It Costs
The guest. A hotel priced and branded as full-service but run with limited-service staffing disappoints. The service gap is where reviews, group business, and repeat loyalty are lost.
The team. Associates and department heads need a visible leader, who coaches in real time and models the standard. A GM at a desk cannot.
The pipeline. If future GMs spend their careers learning compliance and reporting instead of operations, the industry stops producing hoteliers and produces administrators.
The owner. Full-service hotels earn their premium rate from group business, banquets, F&B, and service. Strip those out in the name of efficiency and the hotel is competing against select-service brands on their terms with a higher cost structure.
A Fair Counterpoint
Owners are not villains. Labor costs, insurance, property taxes, brand fees, and debt service rose together, and ADR growth is expected to flatten, so revenue can no longer absorb all of it. Cost control is a real duty. Some cuts, like opt-in housekeeping, may be here to stay and some guests accept them. The question is not whether to manage costs. It is which costs are the hotel's reason for being.
What Owners and Management Companies Can Do
Protect the GM's time. Define what the GM must do personally and what belongs to an accountant, controller, or shared-service center. A GM should not be preparing the bank deposit.
Keep the middle layer. Fund the assistant GM, director of operations, and department heads. They are the shock absorbers.
Measure GM presence. If you track GOP and RevPAR, track floor time, associate engagement, and guest satisfaction too.
Match the model to the brand. If the hotel is full-service in the brand and the rate, staff and operate it that way. If the market only supports a limited-service model, reposition honestly or lease out F&B rather than running a half-version.
Hire for hospitality. Choose GMs for operating and leadership strength first, and give them back-office support.
Closing Thought
The hotel business that many of us loved was a business of people: the walk of the property, the handshake with the group planner, the associate you trained who became a director. The numbers matter, and a good hotelier masters them. But the numbers were always meant to be the result of the hospitality, not a replacement for it. A full-service hotel needs a hotelier in the building, not just in the office.
Resources and Sources
Andrew Carey, Newport Hospitality Group, "Will AI Bring Hotel General Managers Back to the Lobby?" (Hospitality Net, March 2026): https://www.hospitalitynet.org/opinion/4131588/will-ai-bring-hotel-general-managers-back-to-the-lobby
"The role of the hotel managing director is being redefined" (Hospitality.today, summarizing HOTELS): https://www.hospitality.today/article/the-role-of-the-hotel-managing-director-is-being-redefined
"Do Your Own Sheets as a Necessary Cost Saver" (Hospitality Net, 2026): https://www.hospitalitynet.org/opinion/4133913/do-your-own-sheets-as-a-necessary-cost-saver
HVS, "Hotel Profitability in Transition: Cost Pressures and Budgeting Priorities for 2026": https://www.hvs.com/article/10345-hotel-profitability-in-transition-cost-pressures-and-budgeting-priorities-for-2026
Indianapolis Business Journal, "Hotel industry emerges from pandemic with new business model, possibly fewer workers" (Host Hotels CEO on opt-in housekeeping): https://www.ibj.com/articles/hotel-industry-emerges-from-pandemic-with-new-business-model-possibly-fewer-workers
Hotel Business, "Looking forward: Focusing on the future of labor" (housekeeping opt-in rates): https://hotelbusiness.com/looking-forward-focusing-on-the-future-of-labor/
CoStar, "Tips for cost cutting" (owners' panel on F&B, housekeeping, and breakfast costs): https://costar.com/article/1588474000/tips-for-cost-cutting
Lodging Magazine, "Select-service hotels prove efficient, profitable" (CBRE Trends data): https://lodgingmagazine.com/select-service-hotels-prove-efficient-profitable/
UNITE HERE Local 26, "Boston Hotel Workers Join National Day of Action" (Park Hotels operating priorities, a union source): https://www.local26.org/category/press/page/9
One Mile at a Time, "Hilton CEO Warns Hotel Service Cuts Are Permanent": https://onemileatatime.com/hilton-hotel-service-cuts-permanent/
"Full-Service, Select-Service, and Extended-Stay Hotels" (labor hours and margin comparison): https://ibinterviewquestions.com/guides/real-estate-investment-banking/full-service-vs-select-service-extended-stay
Hospitality Net, "The Hotel General Manager of the Future": https://www.hospitalitynet.org/opinion/4124542.html
Note: The point that GMs are now handling bank deposits and bookkeeping is a widely shared practitioner observation, not something these sources measure directly. Adding your own property-level examples would strengthen that section.
Comments
Comments for this content
0 comments available