Curating Wonder the San Vicente Way
At the 2026 Boutique Hotel Owners Conference, Jess Wilner, CEO of San Vicente Clubs, explained how a private club builds pull by saying no, and what hotel owners can borrow from the model.
San Vicente Clubs CEO Jess Wilner shares how the group curates membership by social intelligence over wealth, programs for connection, and applies consistent service across three distinct properties.
Photo by BLLA
"Our brand is saying no to many people," Jess Wilner said.
For a hospitality company, it is an unusual thing to lead with. Most hotels are built to say yes. San Vicente Clubs, the private members club group Wilner leads as CEO, has built its reputation on the opposite instinct: a long waitlist, no public application, and a room curated as carefully as its menu.
In conversation with BLLA's Ariela Kiradjian at this year's Boutique Hotel Owners Conference, Wilner explained how the club decides who belongs, how it keeps a familiar space feeling new on a member's fiftieth visit, and which parts of the private club playbook any hotel owner can borrow tomorrow.
From left to right: Ariela Kiradjian, Partner & COO of BLLA; Jess Wilner, CEO of San Vicente Clubs. — Photo by BLLA
From hourly motel to private club
San Vicente Bungalows opened in West Hollywood in 2018. Wilner described it as a private members club in the spirit of what Soho House originally was. "Our members are paying for access," he said, "access to a social dining space." There are hotel rooms and event spaces, but no wellness program.
The club is the vision of Jeff Klein, owner of the Sunset Tower Hotel. After Soho House arrived in West Hollywood, Klein saw room for something more elevated. Working with friends and family investors, he transformed the San Vicente Inn, a one-star motel that rented by the hour, into a luxury property. Securing entitlements alone took about five years.
Wilner began his career as a night auditor at a small Colorado lodge, a job he took so he could snowboard. He went on to spend years with Ritz-Carlton, then the Beverly Hills Hotel and Hotel Bel-Air, before helping scale Sydell Group. Klein hired him about four years ago to grow San Vicente from one club to three. Santa Monica followed in 2024, and New York's West Village early last year.
Two businesses, one building
The New York club occupies the historic Jane Hotel, built in the early 20th century near the West Side Highway, where surviving passengers of the Titanic were brought after the sinking. Many of its original rooms are tiny: roughly seven feet by five, with a narrow bed and a shared bathroom.
San Vicente bought the building in 2022 and converted its public spaces into the club, with a private entrance. The tiny rooms became a separate business, a 105-key hostel with its own entrance. "We're really operating two very different ends of the hospitality spectrum within one building," Wilner said.
Curating the room
Applications arrive every day. What the membership team looks for, Wilner said, is "social intelligence, curiosity, entrepreneurs, people that you want to have at a dinner party."
The goal is a room that feels like a good wedding: every generation, a range of industries, and people you half-know. "We want you, as you're going to your table, to stop at a couple other tables and say hi to friends," Wilner said. "That's really how we've built the community."
Wealth alone doesn't qualify anyone. "Wealth doesn't make somebody interesting," Wilner said. The club aims for roughly a third of members under 35, a third between 36 and 50, and a third over 50. Wilner estimated the membership is about evenly split between new and inherited wealth.
Editing for diversity
An audience member asked how a referral-based model avoids becoming a room of people who are all alike. Wilner credited the head of membership, a former editor at W magazine, who edits the membership the way she once edited pages. Soon after the New York club opened, she noticed there was almost no one from the theater world. Her solution was to host influential producers for dinner, build buzz, and bring that community in.
West Hollywood presented the opposite problem. The membership leaned heavily toward entertainment, so the club deliberately slowed admissions from that industry to make room for others. Identity, in this model, is actively managed rather than left to chance.
Belonging beyond access
Kiradjian asked the central question for any membership: how do you keep the fiftieth visit from feeling like the first, and make someone feel they belong rather than simply have access?
Wilner's answer was programming. "Those events are opportunities for our members to truly connect with each other," Wilner said. A game night might mean mahjong, canasta, or poker tables. "It's not about the game. It's about the experience of playing with people that you maybe didn't know before." The club draws on its members, too, for Q&As and for film screenings ahead of public release, a natural advantage in West Hollywood.
Don't nickel-and-dime
One philosophy runs through the business. "I don't make money selling a $32 cheeseburger, and I don't try to," Wilner said. The club gives a great deal back to keep members engaged. This past summer, early-week evenings featured a lobster special priced well below what members might expect.
The generosity has a purpose. "That's for you to come in with your friend," Wilner said, "because your friend that's coming into the club is our next round of new members." There is no application on the website. Every new member is referred by an existing one, usually after a great evening as someone's guest. The member experience is the acquisition strategy.
Jess Wilner of San Vicente Clubs on the small touches, from live music to handwritten cards, that make members feel known. — Photo by BLLA
Consistency without sameness
Each San Vicente club has its own designer and character. Two occupy historic buildings with local requirements to respect; Santa Monica is a 1960s building overlooking Ocean Avenue and the treetops toward the pier. What ties them together is service. "We want to have the same arrival process," Wilner said. Menus are about 70% shared, and uniforms and service style are consistent across all three.
Unfussy luxury
Asked what separates a detail that feels intentionally chosen from one that simply feels expensive, Wilner said: "It's really unfussy luxury." The fabrics should be the best, but comfortable. "Somebody may co-work during the day and then have a martini in the same space at night. It's got to be a seamless transition from day to night."
Music follows the same logic. Each room has its own playlist, which shifts through the day, built with the Australian firm Mustard Music using detailed feedback from Klein and Wilner. Santa Monica has live jazz six nights a week, and New York has a singer. "We wanted to have that old-world hospitality feel," Wilner said, "and live music really helps with that."
Time is the luxury
In a crowded New York market, Wilner said, the club succeeds by refusing to drift from what works: consistent food and beverage, strong programming, no wellness, and fast service. "The most important thing our members have is their time," Wilner said. "Everything has to be efficient."
One audience member praised the club for returning to the roots of the members-club model. Wilner summed up the strategy in a line that drew appreciation from the room: "Our goal is to not be hot. It's always to be warm."
When the rooms are the amenity
At San Vicente, guest rooms play a supporting role. New York has nine, which Wilner described as five-star rooms; West Hollywood has eight. All are reserved for members, and priced well below the area's luxury hotels on purpose. The rooms exist to deepen engagement with the club, not to maximize room revenue.
That changes how the team approaches a stay. The club knows a great deal about its members: what they like to eat, when they come, who they bring. That knowledge shapes personalized amenities and handwritten cards for every member staying overnight.
Managing energy on a slow night
A closed community can't fill a quiet dining room with walk-ins. Wilner described several levers for the slow early-week evenings:
Concentrate programming on Mondays and Tuesdays.
Pull tables from the dining room when covers are down, so the room feels full.
Keep the band. "I won't cancel the band on Monday and Tuesday when it's slow," Wilner said. Instead, the band is asked to turn it up.
Cluster reservations around 7 p.m. to create a strong moment of energy.
Investors and lenders often ask how many members a club can support. Wilner said the answer depends on seats and visit frequency. Some members come five times a week, others twice a year, and usage declines only modestly over time.
Pricing is equally an art. "There's certainly no STAR report," Wilner said. The club looks at competitors' dues and its own operating costs, but there is no established formula. "It's really an industry that's still in its infancy," Wilner said. "There's no playbook to follow."
Ideas from the room
Kiradjian turned several questions to the audience, and hotel owners shared club models of their own.
A book club. One Pennsylvania hotel runs a quarterly book subscription for a limited group of members. Members receive the boxes, discounts at the hotel, conversations with authors, and priority access to events, including an annual book ball.
An alumni partnership. An owner in the Berkshires partnered with a Harvard alumni club, offering members worldwide a discounted rate at a property about two hours from campus. Weddings and retreats followed, and an event announced days in advance can still draw a crowd.
Industry nights. One wine-country owner fills slow winter Sundays and Mondays with discounted rates for local winery and restaurant workers on their nights off, keeping costs covered while building community advocates.
Live music as a launch pad. Maya Mallick, owner and creative director of The Culver Hotel, said the hotel's food and beverage business began with live music and a light bar menu in the evenings. Today there is music nearly every night, featuring emerging local artists, plus a daily happy hour named Harry's Hour, after Culver City founder Harry Culver, and weekend afternoon tea.
Music itself drew debate. Kiradjian asked whether owners let bar staff pick the playlist. Answers ranged from strict control to shared ownership, with one operator saying she invites staff to propose music and then reviews it for brand fit. "Again, building that leadership," she said. "You have to get their buy-in."
Ariela Kiradjian of BLLA in conversation with Jess Wilner of San Vicente Clubs on the importance of thoughtful curation, meaningful connections, and a sense of belonging in hospitality. — Photo by BLLA
One thing to try tomorrow
Kiradjian closed by asking what single element of the private club playbook an owner could bring home right away. Wilner's answer was the simplest idea of the session: handwritten cards for guests staying the night. "It's so simple," Wilner said. "People keep them. It resonates."
For owners
Define who it's for. Curiosity and social intelligence make a better room than wealth alone.
Edit the mix on purpose. Recruit the communities you're missing, and slow down the ones that dominate.
Program for connection. Game nights, Q&As, and screenings matter because of who people meet there.
Don't nickel-and-dime. Generosity keeps regulars engaged and brings their friends through the door.
Make referrals the front door. A great evening as someone's guest is the best recruitment there is.
Keep service consistent, let design vary. Arrival, uniforms, and service style can unite properties that look entirely different.
Choose unfussy luxury. The best materials, made comfortable, for spaces that move from day to night.
Curate music room by room and hour by hour. And keep the band on slow nights.
Respect guests' time. Efficiency is a form of luxury.
Write the card. A handwritten note is the easiest piece of the club playbook to borrow.
Comments
Comments for this content
0 comments available