The price-drop regret loop
A 2026 NOVA University Lisbon study of 2M+ reservations found 7.55% of cancellations were same-property rebookings at lower rates, costing hotels an average of €67 per stay.
Two minutes on a Tuesday
Anna makes her reservation for three nights in Lisbon for June. It is March, she pays the flexible rate, and she is pleased with herself for planning ahead for her holidays. One month later her phone buzzes, Google is telling her that the hotel she booked is now cheaper for her dates. She opens the link, books the new rate, cancels the old one, and goes back to her coffee. The whole thing takes two minutes.
For the hotel nothing went wrong, as far as the room is still sold. Occupancy on the pace report has not moved. But the hotel has just given back around 15 percent of that booking's value, and it has taught Anna something she will remember next time: book early, book flexible and then keep watching.
Why guests do it
The feeling behind the click is regret. Nobody likes finding out that they overpaid, so most people will try to get their money back, even if it only a few euros. Behavioral economists have shown for decades in their research that a loss hurts more than an equal gain pleases. Finding out you overpaid for a hotel is a small, very concrete loss. Until recently most guests simply never found out. Now they do, and undoing it costs nothing as long as the rate is refundable.
The second part is habit. When a behaviour pays off, people repeat it. A guest who saved €60 by rebooking once is far more likely to book flexible next time and set an alert straight away. Hotels are not only losing revenue on individual bookings. They are training their own customers to treat a confirmed reservation as a starting price. An attitude that all hoteliers should avoid.
What the numbers say
Until this year there was little hard data on how often this happens. A 2026 study by Martyna Kmiecik and Nuno Antonio at NOVA University Lisbon changed that. They looked at almost two million reservations from 628 Portuguese properties between 2022 and 2024, and matched each cancellation with a cheaper booking for the same property, dates and guests made within one minute. They found out these data:
Finding | Figure |
Share of all cancellations that were rebookings | 7.55% |
Rebookings as share of all reservations, 2022 | 0.67% |
Rebookings as share of all reservations, 2024 | 1.09% |
Average loss per rebooked stay | €67 (16.2%) |
Rebookings made within a month of the original booking | about 80% |
Someone may say that 1% of reservations does not sound liker relevant . But the rate grew by more than half in two years, before Google's hotel price tracking arrived in April 2026. Tools that rebook automatically when a refundable rate drops are now on the market too. The authors also point out that their data had no cancellation fees, so some losses may be smaller in practice, and that guests who moved to another hotel are not counted at all.
Six things a hotel can do
This is not a dynamic pricing best practice, it is just leaving money on the table more likely due to a bad forecast. What can we do to avoid these situations:
Look at the books before you cut the rate. Before dropping a rate, check how many refundable reservations you already hold for those dates. If it is a lot, the cut may cost more than it brings in.
Add value instead of cutting price. Breakfast, parking or a late checkout can lift conversion without showing a lower number to every guest with a price alert. Deceive the tracking app.
Promise your own best price. Tell direct bookers that if your rate on their dates drops, you will lower theirs. It sounds expensive, but those guests would rebook anyway. This way they stay direct, and the regret turns into a reason to trust you.
Make non-refundable a fair deal. A clear discount in exchange for commitment works better than a small one that feels like a penalty. Guests who choose it have nothing to watch.
Count rebookings. Ask your PMS provider or analyst to flag a cancellation followed within minutes by a cheaper booking for the same dates. Most hotels have never measured this, so they do not know what is its impact.
Reward the early bookers. If guests who book first tend to pay the most, they learn to wait. Even small perks for early commitment send the opposite message.
Bottom line
Every price is also a lesson for the guest. When the lowest rate keeps appearing after people have booked, they learn to book, watch and rebook, and the hotel ends up paying for its own flexibility. The fix starts with seeing the problem: count the rebookings, then price as if your existing guests can see every change. Many of them now can and will act on it. Technology is our most valuable tool nowadays but we need to think that our clients also have tools that will help them to move forward.
References
Gondola. (2026, August). Automatic hotel rebooking service. Retrieved November 19, 2026, from https://www.gondola.ai/compare/automatic-hotel-rebooking-service
Google price tracking reshapes the hotel booking journey. (2026, April 22). Hospitality Today. https://www.hospitality.today/article/google-price-tracking-reshapes-the-hotel-booking-journey
Kmiecik, M., & Antonio, N. (2026). Cancel, rebook, save: Revenue leakage from price cuts in hotels. International Journal of Hospitality Management, 135. https://run.unl.pt/server/api/core/bitstreams/e1118499-ff2e-487b-a477-9820aa58e3f9/content
Comments
Comments for this content
0 comments available